El Seminario de Jacques Lacan: El reverso del psicoanálisis (Libro XVII)

What is "The Other Side of Psychoanalysis" about?

This book compiles Jacques Lacan's Seminar XVII, delivered between 1969 and 1970 amidst a context of student and political unrest. In it, Lacan develops his theory of the four discourses: that of the master, that of the university, that of the hysteric, and that of the analyst. Far from being a mere transcription, this work offers a profound reflection on psychoanalysis as a practice and its place in society.

The historical context: 1969-1970

The seminar takes place during the height of the May '68 movement in France. Lacan responds to the revolutionaries' criticisms with his famous phrase: "You are all revolutionaries, but the unconscious is structural." This context gives the work a political and provocative tone, where psychoanalysis confronts the demands for social change. Lacan analyzes how the discourse of the master and that of the university uphold power, while the discourse of the hysteric and the analyst offer avenues of resistance.

The four discourses according to Lacan

The theory of discourses is the core of this seminar. Each discourse represents a structure of social bond: the discourse of the master (traditional power), the discourse of the university (institutional knowledge), the discourse of the hysteric (complaint and demand), and the discourse of the analyst (the production of knowledge about the unconscious). Lacan uses these schemata to explain how subjectivity functions in different spheres. The book includes diagrams and a detailed exposition of each, making it an essential reference for those studying psychoanalysis.

Why is this seminar fundamental?

Seminar XVII marks a turning point in Lacan's work. It is where he first introduces the four discourses and where he links psychoanalysis with social critique. Furthermore, it contains a visit to the University of Vincennes, where Lacan debates with students and professors, showcasing his thought in action. Those who have read this book highlight its depth and its ability to illuminate current issues concerning power and subjectivity. Some readers point out that, although it is a difficult read, the ideas presented are brilliant and revealing.

Reader reviews

Those who have acquired this copy particularly value the clarity with which Lacan explains complex concepts. One reader comments that, despite the difficulty, the work proves transformative for understanding contemporary society. Another highlights the relevance of the seminar for Lacanian psychoanalysis, considering it one of the most important. In general, the edition and Russell Grigg's translation are appreciated, as they facilitate access to a fundamental text.

Frequently asked questions

Do I need prior knowledge to read this book?

Yes, a basic understanding of psychoanalytic theory is recommended, especially of Freud and Lacan's previous seminars. The work is dense and presumes familiarity with concepts such as the unconscious, repetition, and desire.

Is it a beginner's read?

No. It is considered an advanced text within the Lacanian corpus. For beginners, it may be helpful to accompany it with study guides or introductory seminars.

Does it include the famous debate in Vincennes?

Yes, this edition includes Lacan's intervention at the University of Vincennes, where he responds to student criticisms with wit and depth.